22-11-29.  Retirement benefit options.

Text

A. Upon retirement pursuant to the Educational Retirement Act [22-11-1 NMSA 1978], a member may elect, and, except as provided in Subsection D or E of this section, such election shall be irrevocable, to receive the actuarial equivalent of the member’s retirement benefit, as provided in Section 22-11-30 NMSA 1978, to be effective on the member’s retirement in any one of the following optional forms:

     (1) OPTION B. A reduced annuity payable during the member’s life with provision that upon the member’s death the same annuity shall be continued during the life of and paid to the beneficiary designated by the member in writing at the time of electing this option; or

     (2) OPTION C. A reduced annuity payable during the member’s life with provision that upon the member’s death one-half of this same annuity shall be continued during the life of and paid to the beneficiary designated by the member in writing at the time of electing this option.

B. In the case of Options B and C of Subsection A of this section, the actuarial equivalent of the member’s retirement benefit shall be computed on the basis of the lives of both the member and the beneficiary.

C. In the event that the named beneficiary of a retired member who elected Option B or C of Subsection A of this section at the time of retirement predeceases the retired member, the annuity of the retired member shall be adjusted by adding an amount equal to the amount by which the annuity of the retired member was reduced at retirement as a result of the election of Option B or C. The adjustment authorized in this subsection shall be made as follows:

     (1) beginning on the first month following the month in which the named beneficiary of a retiree dies applicable to an annuity received by a retiree who retires after June 30, 1987; or

     (2) beginning on July 1, 1987 applicable to an annuity received by a retiree who retired prior to July 1, 1987 and otherwise qualifies for the adjustment; provided, however, no adjustment shall be made retroactively.

D. A retired member who is being paid an adjusted annuity pursuant to Subsection C of this section because of the death of the named beneficiary may exercise a one-time irrevocable option to designate another individual as the beneficiary and may select either Option B or Option C of Subsection A of this section; provided that:

     (1) the amount of the annuity under the option selected shall be recalculated and have the same actuarial present value, computed on the effective date of the designation, as the annuity being paid to the retired member prior to the designation;

     (2) the designation and the amount of the annuity shall be subject to a court order as provided for in Subsection B of Section 22-11-42 NMSA 1978; and

     (3) the retired member shall pay one hundred dollars ($100) to the board to defray the cost of determining the new annuity amount.

E. A retired member who is being paid an annuity under Option B or C of Subsection A of this section with a living designated beneficiary other than the retired member’s spouse or former spouse may exercise a one-time irrevocable option to deselect the designated beneficiary and elect to:

     (1) designate another beneficiary, provided that:

          (a) the retired member shall not have an option to change from the current form of payment;

          (b) the amount of the annuity under the form of payment shall be recalculated and shall have the same actuarial present value, computed as of the effective date of the designation, as the amount of annuity paid prior to the designation; and

          (c) the retired member shall pay one hundred dollars ($100) to the board to defray the cost of determining the new annuity amount; or

     (2) have future annuity payments made without a reduction as a result of Option B or C.

F. In the event of the death of the member who has not retired and who has completed at least five years’ earned service credit, the member shall be considered as retiring on the first day of the month following the date of death, and the benefits due the surviving beneficiary, computed as of that date, shall, except as provided in Subsection I of this section, be commenced effective on the first day of such month in accordance with the terms of Option B of Subsection A of this section. In lieu of the provisions of Option B, the surviving beneficiary may elect to receive payment of all the contributions made by the member, plus interest at the rate set by the board reduced by the sum of any disability benefits previously received by the member, or the surviving beneficiary may choose to defer receipt of the survivor’s benefit to whatever age the beneficiary chooses up to the time the member would have attained age sixty. If the benefit is thus deferred, it shall be calculated as though the member had retired on the first day of the month in which the beneficiary elects to receive the benefit. In the event of the death of the beneficiary after the death of the member and prior to the date on which the beneficiary has elected to receive the beneficiary’s benefit, the estate of the beneficiary shall be entitled to a refund of the member’s contributions plus interest at the rate earned by the fund during the preceding fiscal year, reduced by the sum of any disability benefits previously received by the member.

G. In the case of death of a retired member who did not elect either Option B or C of Subsection A of this section and before the benefits paid to the member have equaled the sum of the member’s accumulated contributions to the fund plus accumulated interest at the rate set by the board, the balance shall be paid to the beneficiary designated in writing to the director by the member or, if no beneficiary was designated, to the estate of the member.

H. No benefit shall be paid pursuant to this section if the member’s contributions have been refunded pursuant to Section 22-11-15 NMSA 1978.

I. In the case of death of a member with less than five years’ earned service credit or death of a member who has filed with the director a notice rejecting the provisions of Subsection F of this section, which notice shall be revocable by the member at any time prior to retirement, the member’s contributions to the fund plus interest at the rate set by the board shall be paid to the beneficiary designated in writing to the director by the member or, if no beneficiary was designated, to the estate of the member.

J. Any elections of either Option B or C of Subsection A of this section on file with the director on June 30, 1984 by members who have not retired prior to June 30, 1984 are void.

History

HISTORY:
1953 77-9-28, enacted by Laws 1967, ch. 16, § 152; 1977, ch. 314, § 1; 1981, ch. 294, § 2; 1984, ch. 19, § 5; 1987, ch. 86, § 1; 1999, ch. 93, § 2; 2003, ch. 39, § 7; 2011, ch. 122, § 2.

Annotations

Amendment Notes. 

The 2011 amendment, effective July 1, 2011, added “except as provided in Subsection D or E of this section” in the introductory language of (A); added (D) and (E); redesignated former (E) through (H) as (F) through (J); substituted “Subsection I” for “Subsection H” in the first sentence of (F); substituted “Subsection F” for “Subsection E” in (I); added “on June 30, 1984” in (J); and made stylistic changes.

Notes to Decisions

Community property.

Interest.

      Community property.

Trial court erred in directing a husband to name the wife as the person entitled to a survivor’s benefit option under his educational retirement plan; the preferred method of dealing with community interests in a retirement plan that had vested or matured at the time of a dissolution was to value the benefits as a whole, including the value of the survivor’s benefit provision of the plan, to divide, and to distribute the benefits in lump sum or other equivalent distribution. Irwin v. Irwin, 1996-NMCA-007, 121 N.M. 266, 910 P.2d 342, 1995 N.M. App. LEXIS 154 (N.M. Ct. App. 1995).

      Interest.

Beneficiary under Educational Retirement Act was not entitled to interest on the principal amount of retirement contributions remaining in her late husband’s account under former Subsection E of this section (1993) because a 1999 amendment did not apply retroactively and the 1993 version did not explicitly or inherently provide for interest. Wood v. State Educ. Ret. Bd., 2011-NMCA-020, 149 N.M. 455, 250 P.3d 881, 2010 N.M. App. LEXIS 134 (N.M. Ct. App. 2010).

OPINIONS OF ATTORNEY GENERAL

      Generally.

No educational retirement payments are due the designated beneficiary of a member (of the educational retirement association) where that member, having chosen a normal life annuity, died after the effective date of his retirement but before receipt of any benefit payments. 1980 N.M. Op. Att'y Gen. No. 80-32, 1980 N.M. AG LEXIS 9.

Research References and Practice Aids

      Cross references.

Retirement; reemployment, 22-11-25 NMSA 1978.

Death during reemployment, 22-11-26 NMSA 1978.